What Is A Suitable Model ID?

[Pepper II]

There aren't many topics to be discussed in this section outside the individual threads but this is a suitable one. There is never going to be any set of rules which will cover every case so what we ultimately accept as a solve or a model's thread title will always be subjective. None the less here's a chance for everyone to express their opinion. The first two posts here are excerpts from an id request thread and since we really don't want a general discussion there we'll carry on here.

Originally Posted by effCup

Does one photog./studio name outweigh three different mags. using another name?

That is a very good question and I don't know the answer. They're all made up stage names but I personally feel a photographer's website should take precedence over a magazine name most of the time. The exception being if the same name appears in different shoots in different magazines then that may be more acceptable. But no matter what criteria we may choose it is always a judgement call.