Problem Reports, Questions & General Announcements - Page 41

**effCup** · August 12th, 2017, 04:08 PM

This thread for Roni Bell has been called solved, & suggested it might evolve into her model thread (i.e. a PMT), with further research encouraged, yet it is closed to any such new content?

What I wanted to add/suggest was this:

Unnamed on the cover of Man's Magazine, 1975-10.

That image is frustratingly small,

and the timing seems a bit of a stretch, but it also seems the spitting image of the model in Rogue Annual, 1971-Spring.

----

Unintended consequences? I don't think we want a Pending-Pending Model Threads section,

but above illustrates the difficulty--a thread stub we may not want to ditch/delete just yet, but is the solved forum (i.e. the pre- or pending-bin?

) really the right place, either?

Maybe it simply got moved there during a tidy-up with the last post not really attended to? /shrug/

----

Hmm, also Man's Magazine, 1974-10.

**Rubinski** · August 12th, 2017, 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by effCup

This thread for Roni Bell has been called solved, & suggested it might evolve into her model thread (i.e. a PMT), with further research encouraged, yet it is closed to any such new content?

What I wanted to add/suggest was this:

Unnamed on the cover of Man's Magazine, 1975-10.

That image is frustratingly small,

and the timing seems a bit of a stretch, but it also seems the spitting image of the model in Rogue Annual, 1971-Spring.

----

Unintended consequences? I don't think we want a Pending-Pending Model Threads section,

but above illustrates the difficulty--a thread stub we may not want to ditch/delete just yet, but is the solved forum (i.e. the pre- or pending-bin?

) really the right place, either?

Maybe it simply got moved there during a tidy-up with the last post not really attended to? /shrug/

----

Hmm, also Man's Magazine, 1974-10.

Thanks,
Moved back to main. Post at will.

**effCup** · August 18th, 2017, 04:43 PM

Maybe a PMT?

Mod Edit: Seems reasonable; thread moved.

**lualua** · August 18th, 2017, 10:26 PM

Box 2014 #70 = Box 2012 #122

Mod Edit -
Thanks ! Linked and ready

**lualua** · August 23rd, 2017, 08:47 AM

Please merge these two request.
http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...94#post4059994

http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...ight=veruschka
I will edit the two postings so, that the first will contain the ID request and the second the additional pic's
I apologize for the extra work

**BCFC_1982** · August 23rd, 2017, 12:48 PM

Sorted. Thanks

**effCup** · August 26th, 2017, 02:51 PM

Given the naming conventions adopted by classic models mods (softcore & pornstar), MIR may need to reconsider some of the forms used here for settling model ids. Mods. in those sections now prefer model threads to have only one (whether two- or one-part) name for each model thread. Whereas earlier MIR agonised over, for example, how to name this model, and eventually settled on Katia | Chantal as her two best-known one-part handles, with other akas regarded as subsidiary, now her thread uses only the first name, Katia, with Chantal "demoted" to an aka included in the first post.

There are plenty of other such model threads still sitting in MIR awaiting (preferably) a two-part name. One example: Anna | Marina | etc. #1, #2.

I'm not saying we shouldn't still prefer 2-part names, & so the likes of Anna | Marina | etc. can remain in MIR if so desired. My point is about those instances where MIR decides to use more than one (separate) name as with Katia | Chantal. Those will be changed by classic model mods., so is there much point in further agonising over/shuffling additional names, in such cases?

A couple more examples: Elizabeth Baker | Sherrice - Sherrice would be removed from the title & placed in the first post listing of akas.
Jamie Lynn | Robin - Robin would likewise be removed.

It is important/very useful for MIR to find & list such akas for models, but we need also to understand how section mods. will then treat/use that info., so as to not simply create additional work for ourselves/them, switching things backwards & forwards, etc.

Also: classic models mods. have removed publishers from model thread titles--e.g. Mayfair, CeeCee, etc. I haven't checked but they may have similar views as regards e.g. Suze Randall or Digital Desire? #3, #4, #5.

Note: the above comments only apply to classic models, I'm not aware of any of it applying to modern models.

As regards possible clashes of names I've been told classic models mods. will use numbers, e.g. Katia [2], etc., or similar.

**effCup** · September 4th, 2017, 11:33 AM

This box post needs a back-link to here.

Although Matt's image filename says PollyAnn the scan shows Pollyann & Miss Roberts, i.e. Pollyann Roberts, same as this toc listing.

So to recap:

Bold, 1973-08 as Polyann Roberts
Tiger, 1972-Summer as Polyann Roberts
Polyann Roberts - by Ron Vogel

Sir, 1973-01 as Pollyann Roberts

Jaguar, 1972-08 as Clara Worthington
Sir, 1971-12 as Jane Stansil

claimed akas, evidence unseen:

Jeane Allen, Judy Worth, Robin Ryan

also on covers/name(s) unknown:

All Man, 1977-09
Man's Pleasure, 1974-02

I would have thought that was sufficient "weight" of evidence for the name Polyann Roberts? /shrug/ Put her in a thread & then see what else might turn up?

**Rubinski** · September 4th, 2017, 03:56 PM

Thanks Effie!
I added the link, moved the followup thread to the Mystery Corner and changed the name of the thread to
[MB Followup] Big boob Pollyann from Sir magazine January 1973

Does the rest of what you have here need to be in a new post on the followup thread?

Looks like we have a suitable ID for her now.
Solved?

Quote:

Originally Posted by effCup

This box post needs a back-link to here.

Although Matt's image filename says PollyAnn the scan shows Pollyann & Miss Roberts, i.e. Pollyann Roberts, same as this toc listing.

So to recap:

Bold, 1973-08 as Polyann Roberts
Tiger, 1972-Summer as Polyann Roberts
Polyann Roberts - by Ron Vogel

Sir, 1973-01 as Pollyann Roberts

Jaguar, 1972-08 as Clara Worthington
Sir, 1971-12 as Jane Stansil

claimed akas, evidence unseen:

Jeane Allen, Judy Worth, Robin Ryan

also on covers/name(s) unknown:

All Man, 1977-09
Man's Pleasure, 1974-02

I would have thought that was sufficient "weight" of evidence for the name Polyann Roberts? /shrug/ Put her in a thread & then see what else might turn up?

**Pepper II** · September 12th, 2017, 12:30 AM

Hello, everyone. I'm in south Florida and Hurricane Irma has left me with no electricity so I'm using a small generator which isn't capable of running my air conditioning. It's very hot in my office where my computer is so I won't be here much until power is restored.

This means highwayman274 is by himself processing the daily workload so please limit your requests until I return. We like him and don't want him to get overwhelmed, after all, and jump overboard or something.

August 12th, 2017, 04:08 PM	#401
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	This thread for Roni Bell has been called solved, & suggested it might evolve into her model thread (i.e. a PMT), with further research encouraged, yet it is closed to any such new content? What I wanted to add/suggest was this: Unnamed on the cover of Man's Magazine, 1975-10. That image is frustratingly small, and the timing seems a bit of a stretch, but it also seems the spitting image of the model in Rogue Annual, 1971-Spring. ---- Unintended consequences? I don't think we want a Pending-Pending Model Threads section, but above illustrates the difficulty--a thread stub we may not want to ditch/delete just yet, but is the solved forum (i.e. the pre- or pending-bin?) really the right place, either? Maybe it simply got moved there during a tidy-up with the last post not really attended to? /shrug/ ---- Hmm, also Man's Magazine, 1974-10.

August 18th, 2017, 04:43 PM	#403
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	Maybe a PMT? Mod Edit: Seems reasonable; thread moved. Last edited by Pepper II; August 19th, 2017 at 03:48 AM.. Reason: added note

August 23rd, 2017, 08:47 AM	#405
lualua Veteran Member Join Date: Mar 2013 Posts: 1,541 Thanks: 26,114 Thanked 15,422 Times in 1,399 Posts	my mistake Please merge these two request. http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...94#post4059994 http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...ight=veruschka I will edit the two postings so, that the first will contain the ID request and the second the additional pic's I apologize for the extra work

August 23rd, 2017, 12:48 PM	#406
BCFC_1982 Fiona Cooper Enthusiast Join Date: Mar 2014 Location: England Posts: 6,545 Thanks: 109,012 Thanked 106,990 Times in 6,821 Posts	Sorted. Thanks __________________ All my later posts (2017+) have 3% recovery records in the RAR files To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts. PM me in relation to anything Fiona Cooper

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

August 18th, 2017, 10:26 PM	#404
lualua Veteran Member Join Date: Mar 2013 Posts: 1,541 Thanks: 26,114 Thanked 15,422 Times in 1,399 Posts	Box 2014 #70 = Box 2012 #122 Mod Edit - Thanks ! Linked and ready

August 26th, 2017, 02:51 PM	#407
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	Given the naming conventions adopted by classic models mods (softcore & pornstar), MIR may need to reconsider some of the forms used here for settling model ids. Mods. in those sections now prefer model threads to have only one (whether two- or one-part) name for each model thread. Whereas earlier MIR agonised over, for example, how to name this model, and eventually settled on Katia \| Chantal as her two best-known one-part handles, with other akas regarded as subsidiary, now her thread uses only the first name, Katia, with Chantal "demoted" to an aka included in the first post. There are plenty of other such model threads still sitting in MIR awaiting (preferably) a two-part name. One example: Anna \| Marina \| etc. #1, #2. I'm not saying we shouldn't still prefer 2-part names, & so the likes of Anna \| Marina \| etc. can remain in MIR if so desired. My point is about those instances where MIR decides to use more than one (separate) name as with Katia \| Chantal. Those will be changed by classic model mods., so is there much point in further agonising over/shuffling additional names, in such cases? A couple more examples: Elizabeth Baker \| Sherrice - Sherrice would be removed from the title & placed in the first post listing of akas. Jamie Lynn \| Robin - Robin would likewise be removed. It is important/very useful for MIR to find & list such akas for models, but we need also to understand how section mods. will then treat/use that info., so as to not simply create additional work for ourselves/them, switching things backwards & forwards, etc. Also: classic models mods. have removed publishers from model thread titles--e.g. Mayfair, CeeCee, etc. I haven't checked but they may have similar views as regards e.g. Suze Randall or Digital Desire? #3, #4, #5. Note: the above comments only apply to classic models, I'm not aware of any of it applying to modern models. As regards possible clashes of names I've been told classic models mods. will use numbers, e.g. Katia [2], etc., or similar.

September 4th, 2017, 11:33 AM	#408
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	This box post needs a back-link to here. Although Matt's image filename says PollyAnn the scan shows Pollyann & Miss Roberts, i.e. Pollyann Roberts, same as this toc listing. So to recap: Bold, 1973-08 as Polyann Roberts Tiger, 1972-Summer as Polyann Roberts Polyann Roberts - by Ron Vogel Sir, 1973-01 as Pollyann Roberts Jaguar, 1972-08 as Clara Worthington Sir, 1971-12 as Jane Stansil claimed akas, evidence unseen: Jeane Allen, Judy Worth, Robin Ryan also on covers/name(s) unknown: All Man, 1977-09 Man's Pleasure, 1974-02 I would have thought that was sufficient "weight" of evidence for the name Polyann Roberts? /shrug/ Put her in a thread & then see what else might turn up?

September 12th, 2017, 12:30 AM	#410
Pepper II Super Moderator Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Sunny South Florida Posts: 7,852 Thanks: 163,910 Thanked 119,238 Times in 7,641 Posts	Hello, everyone. I'm in south Florida and Hurricane Irma has left me with no electricity so I'm using a small generator which isn't capable of running my air conditioning. It's very hot in my office where my computer is so I won't be here much until power is restored. This means highwayman274 is by himself processing the daily workload so please limit your requests until I return. We like him and don't want him to get overwhelmed, after all, and jump overboard or something.