[MB Followup] melissa

**Meglos** · August 29th, 2015, 03:51 PM

Followup thread for 2015 MB girl here

She could be Lucy Whyte, thread below:

http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...ght=lucy+whyte

**Rubinski** · January 18th, 2017, 11:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meglos

She could be Lucy Whyte, thread below:

http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...ght=lucy+whyte

I think the RG is very similar to Lucy.
Noses and eyes are very close.
Spot on one side of her chin, and above one breast, that seemed to switch sides, along with the part in her hair.

I don't see anything solid saying no.
Looks like the RG did shave the upper portion of her pubic hair.
Lucy's pubes look like a natural bush

**effCup** · January 19th, 2017, 02:55 AM

I'm not sure.

Are the spots on Melissa's chest actually spots on her chest, or are they dust/dirt in the images/scans? I haven't studied every single pic.

but the first few I've looked at it seems like the "spots" are moving, rather than fixed.

Likewise with other spots, e.g. on her legs, that also seem to move so seem again to be dust/dirt.

I'm not saying it can't be Lucy Whyte, but not knowing which (published) Penthouse model Melissa was (could easily be mis-named for the archive) is pretty frustrating.

Lucy Whyte's pics for:

Mayfair, 1981
Fiesta, 1983 as Anthea

were all by John Allum... if we accept that Justin Francis was one of his akas. I don't know who took her Listen with Rustler 02 set. The set from Rustler 07-10, 1983 as Angela was also clearly part of the John Allum Mayfair set.

**effCup** · January 20th, 2017, 08:41 AM

Melissa/mystery does have a "spot", or more like a stained area, on her chest, but I don't see a match for it on Lucy Whyte:

Melissa also has pronounced labia that I think are a different form from Lucy's "wings"?

addendum: on the assumption that models in the Guccione archive are most likely to be those for which Bob was credited by PH, I've looked through his PH models up to 1985 but not noticed any candidates for Melissa.

Maybe I overlooked her.

Maybe it's someone unpublished, or at least unpublished from that setting? Maybe she was published after all but the photog. credited to someone else?

OK, or maybe she dates from 1985+, but I stopped there because the settings were looking increasingly unlike Melissa's.

August 29th, 2015, 03:51 PM	#1
Meglos Veteran Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Nyetimber - West Sussex - England Posts: 1,306 Thanks: 10,569 Thanked 89,347 Times in 1,408 Posts	[MB Followup] melissa Followup thread for 2015 MB girl here She could be Lucy Whyte, thread below: http://vintage-erotica-forum.com/sho...ght=lucy+whyte __________________ Regards Meglos "We Must Know, We Will Know". David Hilbert 1862 - 1943

January 20th, 2017, 08:41 AM	#4
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	Melissa/mystery does have a "spot", or more like a stained area, on her chest, but I don't see a match for it on Lucy Whyte: Melissa also has pronounced labia that I think are a different form from Lucy's "wings"? addendum: on the assumption that models in the Guccione archive are most likely to be those for which Bob was credited by PH, I've looked through his PH models up to 1985 but not noticed any candidates for Melissa. Maybe I overlooked her. Maybe it's someone unpublished, or at least unpublished from that setting? Maybe she was published after all but the photog. credited to someone else? OK, or maybe she dates from 1985+, but I stopped there because the settings were looking increasingly unlike Melissa's. Last edited by effCup; January 20th, 2017 at 01:32 PM..

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

January 19th, 2017, 02:55 AM	#3
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,129 Thanks: 226,701 Thanked 356,679 Times in 21,624 Posts	I'm not sure. Are the spots on Melissa's chest actually spots on her chest, or are they dust/dirt in the images/scans? I haven't studied every single pic. but the first few I've looked at it seems like the "spots" are moving, rather than fixed. Likewise with other spots, e.g. on her legs, that also seem to move so seem again to be dust/dirt. I'm not saying it can't be Lucy Whyte, but not knowing which (published) Penthouse model Melissa was (could easily be mis-named for the archive) is pretty frustrating. Lucy Whyte's pics for: Mayfair, 1981 Fiesta, 1983 as Anthea were all by John Allum... if we accept that Justin Francis was one of his akas. I don't know who took her Listen with Rustler 02 set. The set from Rustler 07-10, 1983 as Angela was also clearly part of the John Allum Mayfair set.