[MB Followup] Sharon Sorrentino or someone else? (a discussion)

**effCup** · May 25th, 2015, 03:07 PM

Followup thread for 2015 MB girl here

Yes, also different eyebrows--Sharon's have a "peak" whereas mystery has a arch/curve.

But I think these two are Sharon, i.e. related to set from Club (US), 1980-08 & CIUK 09, 1980, first post of Sharon's thread.

Quote:

Originally Posted by zjatzjat

edit: mystery also has a different nose--esp. underside.

PALLUCA · May 26th, 2015, 05:55 AM

I agree. She isn't Sharon. It's same girl but not Sharon.

**effCup** · June 18th, 2016, 03:59 PM

Simone from Club (Brazil) no.01, 1981-06, thanks to ramolino530.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramolino530

-> credit to scanner and original poster.

**effCup** · June 19th, 2016, 03:10 AM

Just to clarify: I wasn't meaning the above post with a first-name only as a "solve", just additional content. I actually wasn't sure if mods would want me to add to this query given it had previously been flagged as "solved - no", i.e. confirming not Sharon Sorrentino. On the other hand it would also seem a waste to simply discard this query as I'd still like to know/find a better id for her. I mean, I could open a new query with largely the same content as above, but.

Seemed simpler just to append.

**Pepper II** · June 19th, 2016, 10:30 PM

I've amended the thread title to more accurately describe the purpose of this thread.

**Sixat** · June 20th, 2021, 03:13 PM

Mod Edit: This was a new request now merged.

Fatima aka Chris aka Lucy aka Mia aka Sarah in various magazine posts. Sadly I have no distinct ID for her.

She has been mistaken for Sharon Sorrentino, but as per today that has been ruled out!

As Elspeth in Knave:

Quote:

Originally Posted by skybluepink200

**Russjerk** · June 20th, 2021, 07:48 PM

Lovely pics, Sixat. I think that there are pics of two different models in this request. The three pics from the set where she is called "Sarah", I think, are of a different model. "Sarah's" two front teeth are distinctively larger than the other model's front teeth. Chris/Lucy/Mia/Elspeth does look familiar, though.

**effCup** · June 29th, 2021, 11:43 AM

There's a box post for a non-Sharon Sorrentino model here, with follow-up.

Not accusing Sixat, but I really wished people didn't rename files based upon who they think a model is as it just confuses the heck out of things, especially provenance.

We then have to waste time un-picking the sloppy munging-together that someone else has created.

Just make a folder & put whatever names you like on it, but whatever you do leave the image file names alone.

Sets I know of for the above-linked non-SS are:

Club (Brazil) no.01, 1981-06 as Simone
Club (US), 1980-11 as Francoise - by R. B. Kane
Cover Girls 11, 1981-08 as Maggie
Men Only 45-08, 1980-08 as Simone

All those feature the brown sofa.

Above Sixat adds:

Knave 13-10, 1981-10 as Elspeth - by R. B. Kane

with the red chaise(?).

I agree with Russjerk that there's a different model included above:

Cover Girls 13, 1982-08 as Sarah, thanks to Dry Creek.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dry Creek

-> credit to scanner and original poster.

I don't know who (or where from) is meant by:
Fatima
Chris
Lucy
Mia

Hmm, OK:

Club (Brazil) 01-01, 1981-06 as Fatima
is the same model as Sarah, thanks to ramolino530.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramolino530

-> credit to scanner and original poster.

Cheri, 1983-02 as Mia
is the same model as Elspeth - red chaise. Thanks to mogli63.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mogli63

-> credit to scanner and original poster.

Chris & Lucy still no idea.

BTW, I can post the above sets if required.

**effCup** · July 1st, 2021, 01:53 AM

Re. the other model, i.e. Fatima | Sarah:

Philipa in Men Only 45-04, 1980-04, photog. R. B. Kane. Scans thanks to Cream Cheese.

IFF others agree she's different from the non-SS mystery above, we should split her off into her own query?

----

Can Sixat help with info. on whom/where Chris & Lucy are?

June 20th, 2021, 07:48 PM	#7
Russjerk Vintage Member Join Date: Aug 2016 Posts: 884 Thanks: 3,853 Thanked 8,422 Times in 885 Posts	Lot of AKAs Lovely pics, Sixat. I think that there are pics of two different models in this request. The three pics from the set where she is called "Sarah", I think, are of a different model. "Sarah's" two front teeth are distinctively larger than the other model's front teeth. Chris/Lucy/Mia/Elspeth does look familiar, though.

May 26th, 2015, 05:55 AM	#2
PALLUCA Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 366 Thanks: 133,600 Thanked 5,975 Times in 341 Posts	I agree. She isn't Sharon. It's same girl but not Sharon.

June 19th, 2016, 03:10 AM	#4
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,143 Thanks: 226,789 Thanked 357,031 Times in 21,638 Posts	Just to clarify: I wasn't meaning the above post with a first-name only as a "solve", just additional content. I actually wasn't sure if mods would want me to add to this query given it had previously been flagged as "solved - no", i.e. confirming not Sharon Sorrentino. On the other hand it would also seem a waste to simply discard this query as I'd still like to know/find a better id for her. I mean, I could open a new query with largely the same content as above, but. Seemed simpler just to append.

June 19th, 2016, 10:30 PM	#5
Pepper II Super Moderator Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Sunny South Florida Posts: 7,853 Thanks: 164,061 Thanked 119,274 Times in 7,642 Posts	I've amended the thread title to more accurately describe the purpose of this thread.

July 1st, 2021, 01:53 AM	#9
effCup *Vintage Idiot* Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: History Posts: 22,143 Thanks: 226,789 Thanked 357,031 Times in 21,638 Posts	Re. the other model, i.e. Fatima \| Sarah: Philipa in Men Only 45-04, 1980-04, photog. R. B. Kane. Scans thanks to Cream Cheese. IFF others agree she's different from the non-SS mystery above, we should split her off into her own query? ---- Can Sixat help with info. on whom/where Chris & Lucy are?