View Single Post
Old 02-04-2012, 02:24 PM   #22
Vintage Member
howerd's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: UK
Posts: 1,411
Thanks: 2,417
Thanked 14,063 Times in 1,414 Posts
howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+howerd 50000+
Default I disagree: use max file sizes because of broadband

Originally Posted by Dekoda View Post
Photoshop does a poor job when it comes to jpeg sizes. They have a 1 to 12 scale, while most other programs have a 1 to 100 scale. If you use PS to save an image in jpeg format, a 9 is the best number to use. Anything over that will just make a bigger filesize, but won't result in a better image. If you save the image with a setting of 12, then compare it to a setting of 9....there will be no visible difference.

There is a reason for this. The better way to save a jpeg is with a program that uses the 1 to 100 jpeg settings. With a program like that, I use a setting of 85. This is called the "Q" or quality. This is derived from the five factors of an image.....the red, blue, green, chrominance, and luminance of the picture. When you save a jpeg, you are compressing the image. That means that you are throwing away some of the information in the picture.

You can eliminate the chrominance and the luminance, since they are a product of the brightness of the colors in the picture. The chrominance and luminance make up 20% of the picture, so if you eliminate that, you are left with 80% of the information in the picture. To play it safe, I add an extra 5% of the information, making it 85% or a quality of 85. Anything over that will not be visible in the picture. Saving it at a 12 in Photoshop will not yield any benefits over saving it as a 9.

I agree that using the descreen function will result in a softer picture, but you can regain that sharpness in PS by using the unsharpen mask. If you don't use the descreen function, you will get moire, and that is hard to eliminate.

I also use a black background to eliminate the bleed through that you find in some magazines. I use a black foam board, but any black paper or cardboard will work.

I appreciate the tips ellias. All input is welcome.
I disagree: use max file sizes because of broadband. Programs like Photoshop allow you to use higher compression because of the dial up internet legacy. These days almost everyone has broadband & large Hard Drives for saving larger files. Any compression at all will have a subtile negative effect on images -some of which aren't always apparent in the small square sample Photoshop displays when it asks you to choose a compression level. I choose 'maximum' every time because maximum image quality is much more important than download speed in my humble opinion. There's far too much shoddy scanning on this website!
howerd is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to howerd For This Useful Post: