View Single Post
Old September 25th, 2010, 08:31 PM   #3
jch48
Blocked!
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 300
Thanks: 486
Thanked 2,605 Times in 282 Posts
jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+jch48 25000+
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by scoundrel View Post
Bob Dylan never could hold a tune in a bag. He was always a world class songwriter though.

This is Knocking On Heavens Door: great great song. But if Dylan hadnt written it himself he would just naturally have been hanged from a lamp-post for doing this to it. His ignominious and violent death for this rendition would have been simply the way things had to be.

And yet...I still listened to the whole performance.
Agree with you great song-writer,lousy singer.The story goes Manfred Mann,a great interpreter of his material, was listening to some demoes of Dylans songs,and asked Albert Grossman,Dylans manager why did he use such a terrible singer to record his demoes,to be told,it was actually his Bobness he was listening to.Oops.
jch48 is offline   Reply With Quote