Who are the most UNDERRATED pornstars?
 

1 Lauren Hall
2 Tanya Rivers
3 Brittany Stryker
4 Leena LaBaianca
5 April West
6 Cameo
7 Nicole Londan
8 Nikki Knights
9 Barbara Dare
10 Dana Lynn

Most Overrated: Nina Hartly

Nice topic, taksraven. I believe Susan Hart was on a number of boxcovers, but I loved her to death, so I would agree that she was still underrated.
Definitely agree with elf4736: Nina Hartley has got to be the most overrated.
I'm not into blondes to begin with, plus she worked forever, and was way way over-exposed. I purposefully avoid anything with her in it.

Most Underrated in my opinion
 

I agree totally on Nicole Black

1. Hillary Summers

2. Merle Michaels

3. Tara Aire

4. Trinity Loren

5. Buffy Davis

6. Tanya Foxx

7. Elle Rio

8. Arcadia Lake

9. Kelly Nichols

10. Purple Passion

11. Patti Petite

and in my opinion the most underrated of all Kelli Richards

Love to see any comments on them

From the 70s:

Susan Sloane from NY -- different name in every movie!

Tracy O'Neil, from San Francisco

Siegried Cellier, from Paris

the sandy-haired girl from "Midnight Hustle"

Dianne Dale, from "Marla Strangelove," a dead ringer for the young Kate Winslett, though I think this was her only feature film

in the 80s:

Jacquie Lorians, to me still the prettiest porn actress ever -- always loved her manner, her voice, the hair, the soft body

Siobhan Hunter

Carol Cross

Jen Knoxt

Keli Richards

Sheri St Clair

Rikki Blake

Kendall Marx, who used as many different names as Susan Sloane

Danielle

Probably a dozen others I could think of if it weren't so late

For me
CJ Lain
Carole Pierrac
Suzanne French
LOA
Christine De Schaffer
Michele Raven

my top ten underrated are:
1: Tanya Foxx
2: Regine Bardot
3: Connie Peterson
4: Viper
5: Brittany O'Connell
6: Marine Cartier
7: Helene Chevalier
8: Justine de sade
9: Flame
10: Julianne James

In my humble opinion the order really does not make much difference to me
they are all good

Ten underrated from across the ages in no particular order:

Lauren Brice
Leanna Foxxx
Nikki Knights
Crystal Breeze
Cheri Taylor
Patricia Kennedy
Selena
Laurie Smith
Ruby
Sid Deuce

and two bonus starlets: the underfilmed, underrated

Dorothy Onan iafd
Candi iafd


Oh, I'd have to agree that Nina Hartley's longevity has resulted in overexposure... but I think that she's still one of the all time best (I just wish she'd get a tan ... she's a little too ghosty for my liking these days)

For me has to be ...Underated & Totally Gorgeous
Nicole Black/Noir
Suzanne French
Merle Michaels.

My list:

tamara longley
ali moore
mai lin
april west
kimberly carson
gina valentino
nicole west
krista lane
alexa parks
arcadia lake
lana burner
cheri taylor
ona zee

Most underrated star
 

Biggi Mondi for me, excellent performer.